Self-assessment does occur when pupils assess their particular work, either completed or in-progress. This technique can benefit faculty by saving them time (since self-assessments aren't graded), and it can benefit pupils also. Through self-assessment, pupils improve editing, writing, and critical thinking abilities. But achieving these advantages is dependent upon self-assessment that's rooted in expression. Quite simply, pupils need certainly to exceed assigning by themselves a grade or a rating. They need to manage to mirror upon and articulate the skills and weaknesses within their writing additionally the writing practices that work best to attain the outcomes they desire. While for a few, expression comes naturally, most students must learn how to mirror.


Forms of Reflection

According to Donald Schon (Educating the Reflective Practitioner, 1987), reflection does occur in phases. Reflection-in-action is actively showing, or thinking about a task, or task, while in the midst from it, then making alterations to be able to enhance that task's procedure consequently. Kathleen Blake Yancey (expression within the composing Classroom,1998) develops on Schon's axioms and labels them for the writing process in three stages:

  1. Reflection-in-action, which happens throughout the writing process;

  2. Constructive reflection, which takes place between and among drafts, or revisions;

  3. Reflection-in-presentation, in which formal self-assessment occurs.


Learning to Reflect: Reflection-in-Action and Constructive Reflection

Help pupils practice representation about their writing procedure and products by assigning the immediate following:

Journaling by what occurs throughout the writing procedure is certainly one method for students to apply reflecting, or thinking, about their writing practices. Possibly the most reliable log kind for reflection may be the double-entry or «Dialectical Notebook» as described by Peter Elbow and Pat Belanoff (a residential district of Writers: A Workshop Course written down, second ed., 1995). With this specific technique the writer divides a typical page by a center line, or two facing pages in a side bound spiral notebook, in order to place two items of composing in «dialogue» with each other. Regarding the right part, the great and bad moments in the writing process could be recorded, the analysis, concerns, and/or relevant portions of a conversation with a fellow writer who offered feedback. Regarding the remaining side, records, answers, and/or comments concerning the very first set of notes are recorded.

Logs. Logs are a way for pupils to mirror for action or even to mirror between drafts (constructive expression), that's, because they compose. A highly effective training is for them to start a different word processing file because they compose, then toggle forward and backward between their document in progress and their log, recording ideas because they get. To be able to promote representation while pupils are in the midst of their writing assignments, keep these things:

  • Record moments of indeterminacy, meaning those occasions when they feel stuck plus don't know what to complete next. Exactly how did they resolve the situation? Or had been they in a position to resolve it?

  • Note when something goes particularly well in writing procedure reflecting regarding facets that influenced the process. Did a certain revision method assistance? Did they brainstorm through a tough spot with a classmate or other author?

  • Answer analysis questions during the writing procedure of each assignment which may result in reflection.

Mini essays may be written considering log or log entries, then utilized in peer groups to promote conversation about how the writing and drafting process works for differing people. And/or mini essay might be a letter or memo towards trainer about the writing process, including, introducing the document and explaining how they penned it, exactly what problems they solved, and exactly how well they realized their function or targeted their audience. As soon as pupils have practiced expression and maybe distributed to you or with peers, they'll certainly be prepared for a far more formal, written kind of self-assessment.

Rubrics. An excellent rubric assists pupils realize the requirements always judge composing. Clear objectives spelled down in a rubric should guide the pupil into seeing common issues and an excellent performance. It will explain one of the keys components of the document and describe a reduced, middle, and advanced level of performance. Having students complete a rubric for a real document will help them operationalize and agree with the criteria for a great to exceptional performance. This process of norming (also referred to as calibrating), or visiting agreement as friends on the quantities of performance, ought to be done before a draft is written if at all possible. Then, once a draft is written, pupils utilize the rubric to guage their own performance. This is the same process as can be used in peer review, but students glance at their own work. Self-assessment with a rubric can be carried out instead of peer review, particularly when students never trust their peers, however it could also be used together with it. After students complete the rubric, they need to revise their drafts.


Reflection-in-Presentation, or Formal Self-Assessment

Students who've reflected doing his thing as well as in construction ought to be ready for reflection-in-presentation, or formal self-assessment. Self-assessment is generally assigned due to the fact last act of a writing project. It is often presented when it comes to a «cover letter» or «memo» towards instructor that accompanies a completed product. It may be presented as a mini essay as described above. It may possibly be beneficial to provide prompts that will assist pupils reflect. Prompts can be mainly geared to your program content, this means concentrating on your subject knowledge and everything hoped pupils would gain from the project, with writing particular concerns to arrive as additional. Or the writing particular concerns can take center stage. Following are types of questions often asked in self-assessment prompts:

  • how can you perceive your self as a journalist?

  • What would you like/dislike regarding the writing?

  • What are your strengths/weaknesses in writing?

  • Is composing vital that you you? Do you think it will be as time goes by? What evidence are you experiencing for your answers?

  • just how did you're feeling about that assignment before you began it? Did you believe you'll appreciate it? Did you believe it will be difficult, or simple? How did you are feeling about this once you were completed?

  • What do you like about any of it particular write-up? Just what would you still always alter?

  • Did any specific modification method prove of good use? If so, exactly how?

  • who's the audience for your paper? Just how did you determine the viewers? Exactly how did the audience affect the manner in which you wrote your paper?

Through guided representation and self-assessment, students find out about who they really are as authors, thus gaining the ability essential to think through their particular structure issues critically, and increasing their abilities to edit and proofread unique work. Simultaneously students are making these gains for themselves through self-assessment, they often times offer instructors with valuable understanding of how students learn independently so that instructors might boost their very own practice.


Responding to Self-Assessment

None of the needs to be graded. The mini essays, journals, or dialectical notebooks could be found in peer response groups to come up with conversations about composing and to offer some ideas the more formal reflection-in-presentation. Considering that the formal self-assessment will most likely accompany a larger work which is graded, an easy conclusion grade the self-assessment is all which necessary. However, the formal reflection-in-presentation that's turned in with a writing assignment must be look over and taken care of immediately with marginal responses appropriate on journalist's message; for instance, he or she might need a word of encouragement, praise, or empathy. Your opinions don't need to be long. An easy «I've been there, and I also comprehend,» or «Glad that method worked for you!» goes a long way with pupils. Reflection has great potential whenever you can get students included and motivated.


Additional Resources

Antlitz, S. E. Reflection During Writing: Issues to Ask Regarding The Draft.

Records for Composing a Self-Assessment. The Writing Spot, Northwestern University.

Elbow, Peter and Pat Belanoff. A residential district of Writers: A Workshop Course in Writing 2nd ed.(New York: McGraw- Hill), 1995. Hillocks, George, Jr. Teaching Writing as Reflective Practice (ny: Teacher's College Press), 1995.

How to cite this essay: