Final updated in: 2/28/2017 12:00:22 PM PST | Author:ProCon.org|Comments ()
1. Road to Citizenship — Overview
«There are around 11 million undocumented immigrants currently residing in the usa. Its unrealistic and inhumane to deport him or her from their loved ones and life in the United States. These immigrants ought to be provided a path to appropriate status and eventually received citizenship. This track to citizenship must certanly be practical, in the place of being therefore burdensome it prevents integration. Enabling these immigrants to regularize their status can not only strengthen our national security, but may also stimulate the economy and enhance America's rich, vibrant, and diverse culture.»

AJC (previously American Jewish Committee)
«Path to Legalization for Undocumented Immigrants»
ajc.org
(accessed Feb. 9, 2016)


«As Chairman of your home Judiciary Committee, I have strongly advocated for immigration reform that targets enforcement and upholding the guideline of law, including eradication of enforcement waivers that have been mistreated by past and present Administrations. To be clear, any immigration reform proposal must first guarantee which our immigration legislation are enforced both during the border and within the United States. I stay opposed to amnesty, when I always have been. I do perhaps not support a unique path to citizenship that benefits those who have broken our immigration guidelines.»

Bob Goodlatte, JD
US Representative (R-VA)
«Immigration Reform»
Goodlatte's US home of Representatives website
Mar. 1, 2016


2. Road to Citizenship — Economic Security
«Legal status would increase the economy, nevertheless the ensuing productivity and wage gains is greater in the event that the greater part of this undocumented populace are awarded citizenship. Scientists unearthed that immigrants who are only qualified to receive appropriate status, but not citizenship, would contribute about $832 billion toward economy in a ten 12 months period, add 121,000 more jobs per year, and pay $109 billion in taxes over a ten-year period. Compare that to a scenario where undocumented immigrants are provided legal status and citizenship at precisely the same time, the U.S. GDP would develop by $1.4 trillion over a ten 12 months period, immigrants would help create one more 203,0000 jobs per year, and add $184 billion in taxation revenue. In another scenario where undocumented immigrants are provided appropriate status and citizenship after five years, the GDP would grow by $1.1 trillion, there is an extra 159,000 jobs each year, and include $144 billion in tax income.»

Esther Yu-Hsi Lee, MA
Immigration Reporter for ThinkProgress
«Why Citizenship is way better for America Than Legal Status»
ThinkProgress website
Jan. 31, 2014


«Our nationwide and economic protection rely on needing those who are living and working right here illegally ahead ahead and obtain appropriate because of the legislation. You will see no special way to citizenship for many who broke our country's immigration rules – that would be unjust to those immigrants that have played by the guidelines and damaging to advertising the rule of legislation. Instead, these persons could live lawfully and without fear in U.S., but only when they were ready to admit their culpability, pass rigorous criminal background checks, spend significant fines and straight back fees, develop proficiency in English and United states civics, and then help on their own and their families (without usage of general public benefits). Criminal aliens, gang users, and sex offenders and those that do perhaps not meet with the above requirements will not be entitled to this system. Finally, none with this sometimes happens before certain enforcement triggers have been implemented to satisfy our promise on American people who from here on, our immigration guidelines will certainly be enforced.»

John Boehner
Former United States Representative (R-OH) and Speaker associated with House
«Standards for Immigration Reform»
wsj.com
Jan. 20, 2014


3. Way to Citizenship — Fair Process
"[W]e experience the 11 million people that are here illegally. Everyone concur that these men and women must have to earn their method to citizenship. However for comprehensive immigration reform to exert effort, it should be clear from the outset there is a path to citizenship…

We've got to formulate a path — a procedure that includes passing a background check, spending fees, paying a penalty, learning English, and then visiting the back of line, behind most of the folks who are attempting to come right here lawfully. That is just reasonable, right?..

To ensure means it won't be an instant process however it are going to be a good procedure. And it surely will carry they from the shadows and provide them the opportunity to make their way to a green card and eventually to citizenship."

Barack Obama, JD
44th President associated with the United States
Remarks at Del Sol highschool in Las Vegas
whitehouse.gov
Jan. 29, 2013


«As long as they reach remain in the United States legally, they have jumped before those within their house nations that attempting appropriate entry. The newly legalized unlawful immigrants will be able to have children created here which will be offered automated United states citizenship, with legal rights to numerous means-tested welfare benefits, and non-means-tested entitlements. These kiddies will become the anchors for future citizenship applications from their parents. These benefits will not accrue to people who stay static in their countries while trying to come right here legally.

There is only one good way to ensure that unlawful immigrants go right to the straight back of the line, which the rule of law is respected. Prohibited immigrants must keep the usa without the change in their status in legislation beyond what exactly is available to them under current legislation and current legal regulations promulgated in compliance with present legislation.»

Allan J. Favish, JD
Attorney
«Senator Ted Cruz's Contradictory Position on Prohibited Immigration»
American Thinker website
Mar. 28, 2015


4. Border Fence or Wall
«A nation without boundaries just isn't a nation. There must be a wall across the southern border… Mexico must buy the wall and, until they do, the usa will, among other items: impound all remittance repayments produced from unlawful wages; increase charges on all temporary visas issued to Mexican CEOs and diplomats (assuming necessary cancel them); increases costs on all border crossing cards – that we issue about 1 million to Mexican nationals each year (a significant supply of visa overstays); increase fees at ports of entry towards usa from Mexico [Tariffs and international help cuts are options]. We are going to not be taken advantage of anymore.»

Donald J. Trump
2016 Presidential Candidate
«Immigration Reform that may Make America Great Again»
Trump's 2016 presidential campaign website
May 3, 2016


«Mexican individuals, we have been maybe not going to spend any solitary cent for such a stupid wall surface! And it's going to be completely useless… 1st loser of such a policy will be the usa. If this person [Donald Trump] pretends that shutting the boundaries to anywhere either for trade (or) for folks will offer prosperity towards the united states of america, he's completely crazy.»

Felipe Calderón, MA, MPA
56th President of Mexico
«Mexico Won't Pay a Cent for Trump's ‘Stupid Wall'»
cnbc.com
Feb. 8, 2016


5. Driver's Licenses
«More policy makers attended towards the realization that giving driver's licenses to the undocumented is within the most useful interest of general public security and perfectly appropriate for federal law… Licenses are a privilege that all motorists, citizens and noncitizens alike, must earn. Making certification offered to every motorist who is able to show driving competence decreases the number of uninsured motorists, producing more equitable insurance charges.

…It's in general public interest to acknowledge realities and place the safety of most motorists in front of the politics of immigration. »

Boston world Editorial Board
«Immigration Has nothing in connection with Driving Skills»
Boston Globe website
Sep. 7, 2015


«We are all the descendants of immigrants, and I also definitely help legal immigration, but by issuing papers that legitimize the current presence of those people who have enter into our country illegally, we can not validate the unlawful histories among these people, or their own health histories. Furthermore, I fear that though it is stated why these licenses can't be employed for the goal of voting, that we now have not enough safeguards to prevent it from being abused such a fashion…

This program has caused a huge upsurge in lines at the DMV so when public policy it really is ill-advised and unworkable.»

Rob Sampson
Connecticut State Representative (R)
May 18, 2015 speech
cthousegop.com
May 18, 2015


6. Mass Deportations
«Arresting and deporting females and kiddies in the exact middle of the night time is undoubtedly an awful company. It's also often necessary…

None of those [other immigration] efforts precludes the more powerful enforcement regarding the law in the U.S. This new Year's weekend raids targeted 121 adults and kiddies that an immigration judge had currently purchased taken off the U.S. As harsh as those measures are, they've been in line with the law and send a solid deterrent sign. Despite the outcry, supporting down now would reinforce the misperceptions in Central America that aided produce this issue — and undermine general public support for legal immigration inside U.S.»

Bloomberg View Editorial Board
«Obama's Deportation Raids Are Ugly—and Right»
Bloomberg View website
Jan. 14, 2016


«Locating an incredible number of immigrants for deportation would just take a tremendously dramatic upsurge in domestic surveillance and enforcement, including door-to-door roundups. Mistakes would inevitably be produced, with appropriate immigrants and citizens embroiled in the process. Courts that handle immigration instances will be overrun.

Mass deportations would additionally damage the economy. Most undocumented workers have been in relatively low-skilled jobs, but about a quarter come in white-collar jobs. Of the, about 50 % have been in management, finance or professional careers. Eliminating large numbers might have an extremely significant impact on the businesses that utilize them. Undocumented employees constitute about 5.1% of American workforce at a time when a 4.9% jobless rate shows that labor areas are growing tight.»

United States Of America Today Editorial Board
«The Deportation Deception: Our View»
usatoday.com
Mar. 6, 2016


7. Economic Burden
«The economic effect of unlawful immigration into the U.S. is expensive and impacts the financial safety associated with the county's legal residents… [U]nregulated workers in many cases are underpaid, which will keep wages reduced a certain occupation and region… prohibited aliens can put a financial burden on regional and federal law enforcement… Immigrants normally are apt to have larger families that those in the U.S. This difference can stress the resources of local school districts.»

Michael McDonald, PhD
Assistant Professor in Finance at Fairfield University
«10 Methods prohibited Immigration Affects You Financially»
Go Banking Rates website
Nov. 16, 2015


«Undocumented immigrants contribute dramatically to mention and neighborhood fees, collectively paying an estimated $11.64 billion a year. Efforts vary from almost $2.2 million in Montana with around undocumented populace of 4,000 to over $3.1 billion in California, home to above 3 million undocumented immigrants. Undocumented immigrants nationwide pay an average of approximately 8 % of the incomes in state and local fees.»

Lisa Christensen Gee, JD
Senior Policy Analyst
Matthew Gardner
Senior Fellow
Meg Wiehe, MPA
State Tax Policy Director
Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP)
«Undocumented Immigrants' State and Local Tax Contributions»
itep.org
Feb. 2016


8. Terrorist Threat
«It is an acknowledged fact that since we've refused to secure our edges, we've facilitated the transportation and infiltration of al Qaeda affiliated terrorists and narco-terrorists who are now living illegally in america. This is certainly a critical national safety issue, as manifested by the Boston Marathon bombing…

Fixing our porous edges is certainly one of combating the danger of terrorism that America faces. Any immigration bill should have enforceable border-security measures as a vital national safety element in protecting our country.”

James A. Lyons
Retired Admiral, Former Commander in Chief of this United States Pacific Fleet, and Senior United States Military Representative towards the United Nations
»LYONS: The National safety part of Immigration Reform"
Washington Times website
Aug. 14, 2013


"[I]llegal immigration over the southern US edge isn't a factor to terrorism…

Empirically, the way it is is just false. Foreigners whom've carried out terrorist assaults have entered america legally on immigrant, non-immigrant work/study, or tourist visas. While many of those might have been 'illegal' into the feeling of overstaying their visas, this is certainly a qualitatively different problem than edge crossing."

Start Borders
«Terrorism and Illegal Immigration in the United States»
Open Borders website
(accessed Mar. 14, 2016)


9. Disadvantage United states Workers
"[A]nyone whom informs you that immigration doesn't always have any unwanted effects does not understand how it really works. If the supply of workers rises, the purchase price that firms need certainly to spend to engage employees decreases. Wage trends in the last half-century suggest that a 10 % increase in the number of employees with a specific set of skills most likely lowers the wage of this group by at the very least 3 per cent. Even after the economy has completely adjusted, those skill teams that received the absolute most immigrants will nevertheless offer reduced pay in accordance with the ones that received fewer immigrants.

Both low- and high-skilled natives are affected by the influx of immigrants. But because a disproportionate percentage of immigrants have actually couple of abilities, it is low-skilled United states workers, including many blacks and Hispanics, who've experienced most with this wage plunge. The monetary loss is sizable…

We don't need to rely on complex analytical calculations to understand damage being done to some employees. Just consider how employers have actually reacted. About ten years ago, Crider Inc., a chicken processing plant in Georgia, had been raided by immigration agents, and 75 percent of its workforce vanished over one weekend. Right after, Crider placed an ad into the regional newspaper announcing job spaces at greater wages."

George J. Borjas, PhD
Robert W. Scrivner Professor of Economics and Social Policy at Harvard University
«Yes, Immigration Hurts American Workers»
politico.com
Sep./Oct. 2016


«It may seem intuitive that whenever there is certainly a rise in the supply of employees, those have been right here already makes less cash or lose their jobs. Immigrants [documented and undocumented] never simply raise the availability of work, though; they simultaneously increase interest in it, using the wages they earn to lease apartments, eat foodstuffs, get haircuts, buy cellphones. Which means there are many jobs building apartments, attempting to sell meals, offering haircuts and dispatching the trucks that move those phones. Immigrants increase the size of general population, therefore they boost the size of the economy. Logically, if immigrants were 'stealing' jobs, therefore would every young person leaving school and going into the job market; countries should become poorer as they have bigger. The truth is, definitely, the alternative takes place.»

Adam Davidson
International company and Economics Correspondent at nationwide Public broadcast (NPR)
«Debunking the Myth associated with the Job-Stealing Immigrant»
nytimes.com
Mar. 24, 2015


10. Greater Crime
«75 percent of those regarding the many wanted crooks list in Los Angeles, Phoenix and Albuquerque are illegal aliens.

One quarter of all of the inmates in Ca detention facilities are Mexican nationals, since are far more than 40 per cent of inmates in Arizona and 48 percent in brand new Mexico jails.

Over 53 % of all examined burglaries reported in California, New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona, and Texas are perpetrated by illegal aliens.»

Peter B. Gemma
National Executive Committee Member of the Constitution Party
«Illegal Alien Crime and Violence by the Numbers»
Constitution Party website
(accessed Feb. 27, 2017)


«Between 1990 and 2013, the foreign-born share for the U.S. populace grew from 7.9 % to 13.1 per cent together with wide range of unauthorized immigrants more than tripled from 3.5 million to 11.2 million.
During the same duration, FBI data suggest your violent criminal activity rate declined 48 percent—which included falling prices of aggravated attack, robbery, rape, and murder. Likewise, the home criminal activity price dropped 41 %, including decreasing prices of automobile theft, larceny/robbery, and burglary.»

Walter A. Ewing, PhD
Senior Researcher within United states Immigration Council
Daniel E. Martinez, PhD
Assistant Professor in Department of Sociology at George Washington University
Ruben G. Rumbaut, PhD
Distinguished Professor of Sociology at the University of California at Irvine
«The Criminalization of Immigration into the United States»
American Immigration Council website
July 13, 2015


People who treat this page might also like:
  1. 12 States (and DC) That Allow Driver's Licenses for folks in the Country Illegally
  2. Is Deportation the answer to prohibited Immigration?
  3. 2016 Presidential prospects' jobs on «Should Undocumented Immigrants in the United States be permitted to Become Legal Residents?»
  4. 2016 Presidential Candidates' Positions on «Should the usa continue steadily to Build the Fence/Wall across the US-Mexico Border?»
  5. 2016 Presidential Candidates' jobs on «Should the United States enable Syrian Refugees to the Country?»

How to cite this essay: