Defined Contribution Pension Plans Essay


1.What are the important factors that should be considered by tertiary sector employees when they are deciding whether to place their superannuation contributions in the Defined Benefit Plan or the Investment Choice Plan? What issues relating to the concept of the time value of money may be important in this decision-making process?
2.If the efficient-market hypothesis is true, the pension fund manager might as well select a portfolio with a pin.Explain why this is not the case?



These days, every last individual needs to secure his/her life after the retirement for the employment. They contribute a little piece of their pay in some successful speculation arrangements and retirement arranges. Alongside this, the legislatures of every country offers various venture alternatives, so individuals or representatives may pick suitable choices as indicated by their specific needs. They are allowed to put resources into a solitary alternative or various choices. The strategy holders create suitable speculation methodologies to satisfy their necessities and destinations in an efficacious and an appropriate way. Besides, before putting resources into an arrangement, individuals must see every one of the terms and conditions appropriately to get higher profits for their speculations. There are various essential elements identified with these retirement/speculation arranges that individuals must comprehend to get exceptional yields at lower dangers. Moreover, this examination paper is profitable to portray the critical components that ought to be measured by the workers of tertiary segment to choose whether to put their commitments in the defined benefit plan or the investment choice plan. The paper would likewise be helpful to talk about the real issues identified with the idea of the time estimation of cash that are critical in the basic leadership handle. The paper would be beneficial to exhibit the idea of efficient-market hypothesis in connection to the choice of portfolio.

1. The legislature of the country urges to the representatives to put their superannuation commitments in the defined benefit plan or the investment choice plan; so they can secure their future after their retirement. The administration of country is master dynamic here; and furthermore trusts that defined benefit plans or the investment choice plans are powerful decisions to the workers. The fundamental goal of the administration is to make money related solid to the general population of country. In any case, there are some essential components that ought to be considered by the general population or workers in the determination of these arrangements (McKeown, Kerry, Olynyk and Beal, 2012). These elements are depicted as beneath:

Defined Benefit Plan: Defined benefit plan is a viable retirement arrange for that stipends settled and pre-chosen advantages to workers at the season of retirement. These arrangements are perplexing and expensive to keep up. Be that as it may, the vast majority of the representatives offer significance to such plans because of their settled advantages. There are various components identified with these arrangements that ought to be considered by the representatives before making any sort of speculation. For instance, the main consideration is that the representatives must have adequate information about these arrangements (Feng, Gerrans, and Clark, 2014). Representatives who will partake in such plans have legitimate learning about these arrangements; so they may put their commitments in proper speculation alternatives. Also, representatives must fathom the expense divulgences and costs that are connected with these sorts of venture alternatives and plan administrations.

Then again, the other main consideration is that the representatives ought to comprehend that there is need of yearly installments in such plans. They can't store singular amount sums in these ventures. Additionally, they ought to perceive that these defined benefit plans are unsafe. Workers may confront various difficulties by putting resources into such plans (Broadbent, Palumbo and Woodman, 2006). However, the other reality is that, these arrangements are more secure as contrast with other speculation or benefits arranges. These arrangements give settled comes back to the speculators; and this is the in addition to guide connected toward defined benefit plans. Defined benefit plans are conventional arrangements; and both workers and business contribute similarly in such plans. It is a direct result of the businesses' mange such plans to pay a fitting wage stream to the representatives as opposed to a singular amount measure of their profits. Defined benefit plans are more unique and furthermore give greater retirement security to the workers (Ntalianis and Wise, 2011).

Moreover, before making their superannuation commitments in the defined benefit plan, representatives must comprehend that they need to satisfy every one of the prerequisites that are pronounced under ERISA and IRC act. ERISA sets up models for annuity arrangements to secure the interests of workers in a fitting way. The real prerequisites that are expressed under ERISA and the IRC are plan capability guidelines, financing necessities, announcing and divulgence commitments, installment of premiums, administrative weights, and trustee duties (Brown, Gallery, Gallery and Guest, 2004). In addition, the workers must take mind that they require help of various outsiders like venture supervisors, statisticians, lawyers, advisors, and so on. They ought to satisfy legitimate due tirelessness identified with these arrangements. They should take mind that the arrangements in which they are contributing must be overseen and supported appropriately. They should be skilled to meet the mandatory commitments identified with these arrangements.

Investment Choice Plans: The greater part of the general population work to secure their future after retirement. There is a need of particular speculation arrangements to make the future sheltered and secure. They put their superannuation commitments in various venture arranges. In this circumstance, investment choice plans are more successful choices to contribute. In such plans tertiary segment workers keep an individual venture account (Gallery, Newton, and Palm, 2011). In this record, the workers present the sorts of advantages or portfolios in which they need to contribute their superannuation commitments. There are various components that ought to be considered by workers when they need to put their superannuation commitments in the investment choice plan. These components are depicted as underneath:

Showcase Trends: The central point identified with the past market patterns ought to be considered by the workers before putting their superannuation commitments in such speculation arranges. With the assistance of these patterns, they would have the capacity to realize that how different resource classes have performed before (Foster, 1998). Alongside this, these patterns would likewise be valuable to perceive the slip-ups that the financial specialists have done before arranging their funds. Along these lines, advertise patterns would have the capacity to know the past and current market patterns identified with the speculation arrangements or venture strategies appropriately.

Speculation Need: This is a standout amongst the most imperative elements that ought to be considered by workers before putting their superannuation commitments in such venture arranges. They ought to comprehend that how much returns they need at the season of development. With the assistance of this, they would have the capacity to discover that how much sum they need to contribute to get their coveted returns at the season of development.

Expected Returns: This is a vital variable that is valuable to choose that where they ought to put their superannuation commitments into assets or portfolios. With the assistance of this, they can pick an alternative in like manner to their necessities and desires (Speelman, Clark-Murphy and Gerrans, 2007).

Risk Lenience: the reality of the matter is that such venture arrangements are exceptionally unsafe. The bent to acknowledge hazard is not quite the same as one individual to someone else. The capacity to hazard resilience relies on upon various variables including money related obligations, identity, and condition of individuals (Lewis and Messy, 2012). Thusly, the workers ought to comprehend their capacity to go out on a limb before setting their superannuation commitments in the investment choice plan. It is a result of ability to go for broke is a focal calculates the venture basic leadership handle.

Time Horizon: This is another central point that ought to be considered by tertiary area representatives in the speculation basic leadership. They ought to realize that to what extent they need to keep their superannuation commitments contributed. In addition, the long time-skyline gives higher returns at lower dangers. It is a direct result of the hazard components gather with time (Bodie, Marcus, and Merton, 1988).

Investible Surplus: The workers ought to choose that how much cash they need to put resources into the speculation arranges. Also, the investible surplus assumes a noteworthy part to choose legitimate resource from different resource classes (Tapia and Yermo, 2007). With the assistance of investible excess, they would have the capacity to limit their venture sums and dangers too. These all are the critical elements that ought to be considered by representatives to choose whether to put their superannuation commitments in the defined benefit plan or the investment choice plan.

Concept of Time Value of Money (TVM): The idea of TVM is essential is the speculation basic leadership handled. The workers must consider TVM idea to choose that the defined benefit plan or the speculation decision plan would be proper to put their superannuation commitments. Alongside this, the idea of TVM is exceptionally useful to decide the present esteem, future esteem, annuity installment, financing cost, and number of times of a speculation. The significant issue that is identified with the idea of TVM is that it is extremely mind boggling. Speculators confront loads of challenges to figure estimations of their venture. In any case, the significant certainty that is identified with this idea is that it offers exact counts; and with the assistance of this workers may verify that how much cash they have to contribute to get their coveted returns later (Gutmann, 2013). With the assistance of this, tertiary division workers would have the capacity to realize that cash that they have at this moment is worth more than a similar sum later on account of its potential winning limit. In perspective of that, the idea of the TVM might be imperative in such speculation basic leadership forms.

2. The EMH (efficient-market hypothesis) is a viable hypothesis that is useful in the venture basic leadership prepare. With the assistance of efficient-market hypothesis, financial specialists can settle on venture choices to get significant yields. As indicated by EMH hypothesis of speculation, speculators can get all the data identified with the money related parts of the business associations. It is a result of security costs of business firms depicts all the money related data of the organizations before financial specialists (Lee, Lee and Lee, 2009). The EMH attests that financial specialists are purchasing appropriate stocks. The costs of their stocks are reasonable. The principle explanation for it is that by considering the EMH hypothesis, business firms exchange their stocks just at reasonable costs. Efficient-market hypothesis is profitable to anticipate future patterns in the commercial center.

Alongside this, the benefits support director accentuation on EMH hypothesis to choose a portfolio to give exceptional yields to the financial specialists. The manger cannot pick a portfolio with a pin just when the proficient market theory is valid. There are various causes behind this. Above all else, the efficient-market hypothesis never says to pick a portfolio with a stick. It is a result of if the director will choose a portfolio with a stick then there is not surety that financial specialists will get exceptional yields on every one of these portfolios. The chief must consider the way that all the accessible portfolios or stocks are not all around enhanced (Graham and Dodd, 2008). In this circumstance, a portfolio with a stick might be unsafe to the financial specialists. The pension fund manager ought to concentrate only on one portfolio that may give significant yields to the financial specialists at exceptionally bring down level of hazard.

Then again, the supervisor ought to consider advertise patterns and arrangements to settle on such sorts of choices. As indicated by the market patterns and strategies, the speculators ought to just choose a very much expanded portfolio as opposed to portfolio with a stick. A very much enhanced dependably works in the great deed of financial specialists; and gives higher comes back to the speculators. Alongside this, the benefits support chief ought to pick a less dangerous portfolio rather than more hazardous portfolio with a stick. Besides, the director must guarantee that they chose portfolio will give impose refunds to financial specialists. Thus, these market approaches and patterns ought to be taken after before choosing a portfolio to a financial specialist. A portfolio with a stick would not have the capacity to satisfy the desires and offer significant yields to speculators (Brealey, Myers, Allen and Mohanty, 2012). In perspective of that, the reserve administrator ought not to pick a portfolio with a stick regardless of the possibility that the efficient-market hypothesis is valid.


On the premise of the above investigation, one might say that, speculation arranges assume a noteworthy part to secure the fate of individuals. In any case, there are various elements that must be consider before putting cash in the characterized befit plan or investment choice plan. Alongside this, it is analyzed that, the powerful market speculation is a useful venture hypothesis. Individuals must consider every one of the truths of this hypothesis to settle on choices identified with the speculations. So, it is recommended that, the employees should invest their funds in the plans that are proficient to provide high returns at lower costs. These plans should be safe and risk free.


Bodie, Z., Marcus, A.J. and Merton, R.C. (1988). Defined benefit versus defined contribution pension plans: What are the real trade-offs? In Pensions in the US Economy (pp. 139-162). University of Chicago Press.

Brealey, R.A., Myers, S.C., Allen, F. and Mohanty, P. (2012). Principles of Corporate Finance. NY: Tata McGraw-Hill Companies Inc.

Broadbent, J., Palumbo, M. and Woodman, E. (2006). The shift from defined benefit to defined contribution pension plans–implications for asset allocation and risk management. Reserve Bank of Australia, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and Bank of Canada, pp.1-54.

Brown, K., Gallery, G., Gallery, N. and Guest, R. (2004). Employees’ choice of superannuation plan: effects of risk transfer costs. Journal of Industrial Relations, 46(1), pp.1-20.

Feng, J., Gerrans, P. and Clark, G. (2014). Understanding superannuation contribution decisions: Theory and evidence. Available At: [Accessed On: 10th May 2017]

Foster, A.C. (1998). Factors affecting employer-provided retirement benefits. Compensation and Working Conditions, 3(4), pp.10-17.

Gallery, N., Newton, C. and Palm, C. (2011). Framework for assessing financial literacy and superannuation investment choice decisions. Australasian Accounting Business & Finance Journal, 5(2), p.3.

Graham, B. and Dodd, D.L.F. (2008). Security Analysis (6th ed.). USA: Tata McGraw-Hill Companies Inc.

Gutmann, A. (2013). How to Be an Investment Banker: Recruiting, Interviewing, and Landing the Job. UK: John Wiley & Sons.

Lee, A.C., Lee, J.C. and Lee, C.F. (2009). Financial Analysis, Planning & Forecasting: Theory and Application. USA: World Scientific.

Lewis, S. and Messy, F.A. (2012). Financial education, savings and investments: An overview. OECD Working Papers on Finance, Insurance and Private Pensions, (22), p.1.

McKeown, W., Kerry, M., Olynyk, M. and Beal, D. (2012). Financial Planning, Google eBook. USA: John Wiley & Sons.

Ntalianis, M. and Wise, V. (2011). The role of financial education in retirement planning. Australasian Accounting Business & Finance Journal, 5(2), p.23.

Speelman, C.P., Clark-Murphy, M. and Gerrans, P. (2007). Decision making clusters in retirement savings: Preliminary findings. Australian Journal of Labour Economics, 10(2), p.115.

Tapia, W. and Yermo, J. (2007). Implications of behavioural economics for mandatory individual account pension systems. OECD Working Papers on Insurance and Private Pensions No. 11. OECD Publishing.

How to cite this essay: