Before I Die: Opinions Essay


Michael H. White, J.D.

Physician-assisted suicide is a legal medical procedure for competent, terminally ill adults, because it is a compassionate reaction to relieve the suffering of dying clients. Controversy about any of it is due to fear that susceptible populations could be coerced into early death, on the one hand, and from fear that dying and helpless clients can be either abandoned or subjected to unwanted and unnecessary medical treatments, alternatively.

In a workable system, the choice of physician-assisted committing suicide would arise only all things considered treatment plans are exhausted, the very best of hospice and palliative care has did not alleviate intolerable suffering, if a mentally competent client continues to request support in dying. Then, with outside viewpoint concurring, doctor will be allowed to prescribe medication that the client can use to hasten death at a time regarding the patient's option.

These safeguards would preclude punishment for the handicapped, the incompetent, minorities, seniors, or other susceptible populations. Individual and family members anxiety about future suffering and death is paid off; care and convenience at the end of life would be improved. The individual could get this many private and basic of choices actually, without unwarranted and unneeded intrusion by the state or religious opposition.

A more logical law than the current ban on assisting a terminally sick client whom requests help in dying will expand the size of lives of these who are dying by preventing the committing suicide of the who will take advantage of relieved suffering.


Tracy E. Miller, J.D.

The two most typical reasons that lead people to consider or to commit suicide, whether they are terminally ill or otherwise not, are untreated discomfort or depression. Offered treatment plan for pain and depression, most patients, also people that have AIDS or cancer tumors, elect to live much longer, to not kill by themselves.

Unfortunately, frequently, physicians aren't taught to offer sufficient treatment plan for discomfort or despair. Consequently, many patients believe that they've just two feasible options: to commit suicide or to suffer. But good medical care can provide clients relief from discomfort and control over their medical destiny without creating the severe dangers posed by assisted suicide.

Legalizing assisted suicide could be profoundly dangerous. The risks would extend to all or any who're ill, but could be greatest for patients who lack access to quality health care. The gravest danger isn't that doctors or members of the family will likely to be abusive. Other risks may be subtle and more common: senior clients who concern yourself with being an encumbrance; doctors who're not ill-intentioned but hurried or insensitive; clients who believe they have no additional options. Just what will it suggest to patients if physicians recommend committing suicide in the place of treatment or care? A request for suicide is generally a plea for assistance. Exactly how many physicians understand their clients sufficiently to hear that plea?

As a culture, we ought to commit ourselves to caring better for clients at life's end. Authorizing medical practioners to assist committing suicide is an easy, but a lot more dangerous, solution.

How to cite this essay: